To that end, try to relate course content either to current events or to your students’ lives and work. To ensure we, as faculty, connect with our students and deliver quality online learning experiences, we must re-think the ways we can engage with them to increase their level of participation so that students can reap all of the benefits of elearning. Toll Free This shows that you value them and allows you to identify at-risk students. An online community enhances the student’s learning experience while also giving them the chance to connect with their peers. Communicate in multiple formats Online education provides instructors with multiple avenues for communicating with students. Follow-up on all questions – either privately or publicly. You can change norms. Company Number: 234574 To keep students engaged, return online assignments quickly and with substantive feedback. Forums are also the most interactive part of the classroom where students get to interact with each other and the online teacher has the most chance to bond with their students and create a sense of community in the online classroom. participate in their own learning process and sometimes even in course design Studies show that those who aren’t intrinsically motivated tend to lose interest in discussions as the course goes on. Highlight the good points your students have made. By submitting your information, you agree to the processing of your personal data as per Wiley's privacy policy. Writing about what they’re learning helps them retain that knowledge. Online discussion forums. Post discussion guidelines in the online community, for example, ask students to respond thoughtfully and ask open-ended questions. To replicate on-campus learning experiences online, respond frequently to your students individually – whether it’s private or public. In an online course, often students are working alone without interaction with others. Teaching Strategies for Small Group Discussion; How to Engage Introverts in Classroom Discussion; 7 Free Online Discussion Tools; 10 Student Led Discussion Strategies for Spicy Discussion . It could be something as simple as asking students to get up and take two rounds of the room they are sitting in or having them jump on the spot … Discussion topics and questions must be aligned with the … Learning online is … The instructor must ensure that meaningful conversation takes place. Discussions are driven by questions – so ask. We wanted to use this data to develop a variety of strategies for faculty to use to better engage their students. Here are a few ideas for increasing and ensuring higher levels of student engagement in online courses: 1. Discussion Design and Facilitation. How is it working/or not working for them? A number of steps can be taken to promote an engaging and interactive online discussion, beginning with drafting the discussion questions that students are asked to respond to. Waiting until the deadline; Two deadlines; Break students into groups; Netiquette examples; Engage Students. You’ll end up with too many redundant discussion threads of questionable value—a real turn-off. At the beginning of a course, online discussion tends to be between the instructor(s) and students. Periodically ask your students what’s good (or bad) about a particular discussion. Telephone Discussions must be built into the course design and tied to learning objectives. 38 Spring Street In every classroom, there are students who always have their hand raised to participate, and those who are hesitant to engage. They are not fixed. We’ve been doing some studying of our own and found a dozen tactics that will help you get students more involved in online discussions. P.O. Encourage students to ask additional questions during the guest’s stay. Keep track of thoughtful or insightful questions and comments, especially if online discussion participation is required. Provide suggestions for related content if students want to go deeper on a topic. One method for increasing student engagement that has been gaining in popularity is engaging students in role play activities. Communicate your expectations for participation and behavior online. Record videos using your webcam, smartphone, etc., and upload the files to YouTube, Vimeo, screencast.com, or use a service like VoiceThread. Once I have introduced a topic and am confident that my students understand the solving process, I will guide them through a problem and intentionally make common errors. On the other hand, when students aren’t putting enough effort into their contributions, send them a private message too. If there’s more than one moderator, ask them to split up the days so they have time off during the week. You want students to have a sense of purpose that fuels their course participation and engagement. A debate is a formal competition between two teams, usually with three members each, arguing a discussion statement known as “the moot”. “Flipping” the question, or restating it using different terms, can help students understand the discussion better. Instead, consider requiring a specified number of thoughtful remarks either in initial posts or responses. When using personalized videos, ensure you look into the camera to appear that you are making eye contact. One definition of active learning is “hands-on learning,” although that could probably include “hands-on your mouse,” which is not the … Don’t be all business. Whether they’re introverted, tend to think awhile before they contribute, or are just having a bad day, it can be hard to bring kids into discussions who are reluctant to add their voices. Watch the video and see the accompanying handout for examples of constructivist approaches to discussion design and facilitation strategies. If you notice some students have not been adequately participating in the discussion, send reminder emails to them individually to encourage their participation. Teachers can prompt students in online collaboration activities by creating chat and discussion rooms or building online quizzes featuring the most interesting topics from the lesson. In online courses, students have been shown to demonstrate more positive attitudes and greater levels of performance when discussion boards are highly interactive. Students who have been or will be assigned the moderator role are more likely to participate in discussions because they empathize with the moderator or hope they’ll pay back the favor. Share your observations and provide some advice on how to better approach the discussion requirement. The Transformation of Corporate Diversity eBook, The Power of Flexible Partnership: Case Studies of a Diverse Group of Institutions, A Guide to Online Bachelor’s Degrees Post Pandemic, Different Learning Methods to Support Students and Faculty, Incorporating Storytelling to Promote Online Learning, Five Components to Provide Quality Online Instruction. Let them choose which topics or forums they want to moderate on a first-come, first-served basis. But what can you do to increase student participation in online discussions? Student engagement is a challenge for any teacher. Setup is quick and easy: Teachers sign up, name their chat, and give students the URL. Utilizing the above tips as you implement an online discussion will go a long way in student relationship management, increasing your presence, and encouraging creative thinking in the online classroom. Students take responsibility for sustaining the discussion Ask students to come to the virtual discussion with at least one question they would like to discuss. Provide guidelines to your student moderators, for example, check the community X times a day, and post at least X number of questions and X number of responses. That might be true if the course is designed that way, but one way to engage online learners is to get them out of their chairs (or beds) and get them involved in active learning. Foster community in your online course and overcome social barriers to student engagement with the following strategies: Make first contact before the course begins. But, to ensure you’re not playing favorites, keep track of your accolades so you don’t create an unintentional teacher’s pet. Prepare a running Q&A session or interview by fielding questions from students ahead of time. +353 1 417 0100 See how many of these proven tactics you can use in your online learning programs. Take time to explain to students why online discussions are an essential part of the learning experience—how they provide continual opportunities to reflect, recall, and apply new knowledge. Get evidence from the get-go. At the end of each module, review some of the issues and themes that emerged from online discussions. Perfect! The discussion forums are the heart and soul of your online classroom. Or worse yet, in a compendium of Tweets compiled by an aggregator such as Buzzfeed (Martinez, 2019). Strategies for Engaging Discussions Engagement and Re-engagement Edelstein and Edwards (2002) suggested that “One of the chief tenets for a successful and engaging online course is the development of an effective system that provides ongoing student interaction” (para. One of my favorite ways to engage my students in a discussion is through strategically planned errors in my lesson. Knol sets the expectation that her students will use textual evidence, and she tells students to “prove it” so often that they anticipate her request, have their texts open, and often return to … Always be open with your students and they will respond in kind. Signs of an Engaging Discussion. If you spot a stubborn lurker, explain to them that this tendency inhibits their learning experience—and affects their grade. But as the course progresses, students increasingly talk to each other instead of only to the instructor(s). Participation in online discussions should be mandatory. Dozens of studies have come to the same conclusion: online discussions strengthen student engagement and learning. Ideally, the boards not only fuel student engagement, but they also facilitate critical thinking and a sense of community in online environments. First, you should always observe and monitor the discussion. Send an email message to introduce yourself and provide instructions on how to get started. Encourage students to have constructive and considerate disagreement. In this model, students attain a cognitive presence in the community through forming their own inquiries. You don’t have to respond to all posts – that may stifle a real discussion. +1(877) WBT-7700, WBT Systems Limited But when you’re doing corporate training for adults, it gets even harder. Provide tips for time management. Ask students to generate their own discussion questions. Emoticons and symbols add value to the conversation when implemented sparingly. Require students to have evidence ready at the start of the discussion. Shifting the workload toward the students. It’s engaging, fun and they can use their own devices! Remind students how their new knowledge and skills will help them make a difference in the world, even in small ways. Crack a joke, ask students to solve a puzzle, throw in random trivia—it is always a good idea to include a surprise element in your online class. Nashua Beyond the Discussion Board: How Can I Engage Online Students? Backchannel Chat's moderated online discussions are intended to engage students and encourage them to share. “I know it’s common for online students to not succeed at the same levels as face-to-face students,” said Robert Rivas, Executive Director of Innovation and Research. Personal conversations help students build relationships and a sense of community. Online learning is a … However, there is more your students can do with Google than publish, engage in digital notebooks, make presentations, and complete assessments. Acknowledge the time constraints experienced by full-time professionals who take online courses. Dublin 2 Students do not provide resolutions too quickly or easily, and do not struggle too much. Recalling and applying information is part of the learning process—it’s required to make learning stick. Block 2, Harcourt Centre Tell students how they’ll be evaluated on their discussion contributions and how online community participation factors into their grade. This sense of belonging is a motivating factor for continuing discussion participation as time goes on. Follow-up on all questions – either privately or publicly. They don’t engage students easily, and they can’t duplicate the dynamics of a face-to-face classroom discussion. Encourage your students to do the same. Moderators feel a sense of ownership—a motivating emotion. Different Ways To Make Online Discussion Forums Engaging And Fun. Explain the value of diverse perspectives. One side puts forth an argument and the other side responds with an opposing argument. The best thing about online discussion forums is that all students can be active at the same time, discussing the topic instead of raising their hands and waiting to be called on. Bonni recommends: Michael hyatt's ideal week blog post and template This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. Registered in Ireland. Engage students in their own learning with discussion prompts designed to get students talking. They’re more likely to be passive participants who are happy to read but not comment. This will draw on not only what they’ve learned from the class, but also what they’ve gathered from their life experiences. If students post inappropriate information, intervene immediately. If you are a tech-savvy soul, you will also want to check out this post about tech discussion strategies and tools for student discussion. Online asynchronous discussions are often incorporated by faculty into blended or online courses, providing opportunities for rich dialog among students outside of the traditional face-to-face classroom environment. Keep in mind that students must be intrinsically motivated to engage fully in their learning experience. Harcourt Street The instructor must ensure that meaningful conversation takes place. Assigning student moderators has a positive impact on the learning experience: If things get too quiet or if everyone is too agreeable, say something that elicits disagreement or gets students to argue for the opposing viewpoint. Despite their universal use in online teaching, discussion boards have significant drawbacks for educators and students alike. It’s okay to challenge and disagree with each other but only if it’s done in a kind manner. Guide your students to go deeper and think critically about the subject matter outside of what is provided in the course materials. A common default for online discussions is requiring each student to start a discussion thread every week. The Fight Against Racism and Social Injustice, The Use of Mobile Devices in Online Classrooms, The Recipe to Become a Successful Virtual Instructor, Foster Engagement in Your Virtual Classroom, Preparing for and Teaching Video-Based Class Sessions, How to Promote Engagement in Virtual Classes. Yikes. Discussions must be built into the course design and tied to learning objectives. Send a private positive message to students who make valuable contributions. Provide feedback to the moderators as they go. What could be improved? Discussions give students the opportunity to reflect upon and apply what they’ve learned. “Knowing that’s true for us, we had to do something.” Based on the success of their campus-wide Drop-Rate Improvement Program, they appli… +353 1 478 5544, Sign up to our newsletter to be the first to receive our blog and updates, opportunity to reflect upon and apply what they’ve learned, online discussions are an essential part of the learning experience, online community enhances the student’s learning experience, Improve Student Success with an Online Learning Community, 3 Ways Your LMS Facilitates Reflective Learning, 3 Ways an Online Community Enhances Learning, 12 Ways to Increase Student Participation in Online Discussions. Affirm (but don’t flatter) your students collectively and individually, with recognition of what they brought to the discussion. Point out any conversations in the personal forum that the guest might want to dive into. Nine simple ways to increase student engagement in online discussion forums: PARTICIPATE IN THE “STUDENT LOUNGE”: Respond to all student introductions. In this case, they may lose their train of thought or forget to listen to what the speaker is saying because they’re forming … NH 03060-0801 Also, if students don’t have an opportunity to socialize, they might go off-topic in the course discussion forums. Chime in throughout the week so students don’t feel like you’ve checked out on them, but be careful not to steal their thunder. However, some people still prefer to lurk in online forums. Furthermore, these authors reminded online instructors that if students are expected to participate in the discussion D uring the past year and a half, our faculty development unit has been gathering data from students about how engaged they felt in their online courses. You incorporate humor, images, and frame your responses and statements for students to better understand you. This You’ll see it on anonymous discussion boards like Reddit. Your students will model how you relate to them. Similarly, students who may be shy or more hesitant to engage in real-time conversation can prepare some “talking points” in advance of the synchronous session, so they feel comfortable engaging. Suggest a baseline amount of time to dedicate to online discussions. Students participate early and adhere to deadlines and timelines. Pose an open-ended yet specific question. United States, Telephone As a result everyone talks to each other and students don’t feel alone. That’s where online discussion boards come into play! Students who read all their fellow students’ postings consistently get higher grades, so you should do the same. Post your own introduction and talk about both your personal and professional background. Discussion topics and questions must be aligned with the curriculum. Respond to all student introductions. Make use of breakout rooms to get students together for discussions. Guidance and facilitation from faculty should encourage discussion. Recommendations. This helps them learn more. Some students find it hard to follow conversation threads. A sense of community develops—a motivating factor when the going gets tough. You could do this as a weekly video. Split them into two groups. However, this practice leads to a cluttered forum. WBT Systems, Inc. Discussion boards also fuel an impressive level of student contempt. Qualify your tone if necessary. They should know that what they’re doing here matters. During a discussion, they recall information, put it into context, and ask questions that require them and their classmates to review what they’ve learned. 1). You have your lesson materials. These activities can vary in scale from large, multi-day events (such as Reacting to the Past) to smaller activities contained within one class meeting (Carnes, 2014). 3. When you ask, be sure to acknowledge and act on their comments if needed. Box 801 A common misconception about online learning is that students only sit in front of their computers. Students come to your association for education, but everyone also values networking and relationship-building—that’s one of the top reasons members join associations. You have a group of individuals with different learning styles. NEVER TYPE IN ALL CAPS. Use this forum for initial introductions. 2. For more best practices in engaging online learning environments , such as better utilizing media or increasing faculty-student engagement online, visit our Resources page. How to increase student participation in online discussions. Try asking the question in a different way. Ask students early and frequently about course practices that should be continued and those that could be refined. Post your own introduction and talk about both your personal and professional background. With minimal effort on the instructor’s part it is indeed possible to engage students despite having little to no face-to-face contact. Your students will model how you relate to them. The affirmation may even be part of the framing you use to then ask them a question or encourage them to go deeper. Think of it as a teacher-moderated, private version of Twitter, where students can discuss topics that might just transcend the virtual space. Take time to provide individual (and private) coaching until they get the hang of it. Find a hot topic—a news item or industry development—and have students debate it. See how many of these proven tactics you can use in your online learning programs. Their job is to encourage and facilitate conversation. Provide public feedback as well. During a whole-class discussions, or even a small group discussion, students need to wait their turn to speak. Student-generated debate presentations can become a welcome change from the call and response format of the typical online discussion boa… Students and teachers can actually have analytical discussions and debates. Online discussion fosters collaboration and higher order thinking skills that better prepare students for the … To analyze conceptual engagement in students' online discussion, we coded all forum posts in two sections using the “speaking variables” scheme, which comprises five dimensions: Argumentation, Responsiveness, Elicitation, Reflection on Individual Processes, and Reflection on Group Processes (Wise, Zhao et al., 2014). But, I believe that online discussions foster a sense of community and connection between the teachers and the students and each other. This encourages them to think about the topic the group will be discussing in advance of the conversation and identify some aspect of the topic that interests them. Invite a guest expert to visit the online community for a few days. Fax If you really want to make your online course stand out from competition, use media to illustrate a point, create more conversation, inject humor, or just for fun. To build an assessment discussion forum that engages students, provide open-ended prompts that allow for in-depth discussion. Throw In A Surprise Element. +1(603) 654-3500 If nothing seems to work, you may want to replace the question totally, or simply ask the question: “We seem to have some difficulty with this question, why do you think that is?”. Avoid the overuse of exclamation points! Students reflect thoughtfully on relevant content and refer to course concepts and materials. Online discussions also give students a chance to interact with each other and build relationships. I will then wait for students to point these out. Studies have found that more students participate in online discussions than they do in classroom discussions, even introverts. You could call your forum for off-topic discussions the Student Lounge, Break Room, or Water Cooler. And when that training is happening online, involving you, your LMS, and a bunch of screens? You have a discussion board. Seed a new conversation by asking students to share time management hacks. Odessa College, a community college in Texas with more than 8,000 students, wanted to improve their online course success rates. Your interaction encourages students to post more often and stay engaged. The Community of Inquiry (CoI) model, developed by researcher Randy Garrison, makes the case that online discussion is most effective when students have a cognitive presence, a social presence and a teaching presence in the discussion. VAT Number: IE8234574D Adjusting the question language/verbiage, and by asking students to answer questions collaboratively, can make for a much more meaningful learning experience. #1: Embed online discussion into course design. 1. Instead, give students the “space” to respond to each other. After a few weeks of taking the lead, assign the moderator role to one or more students, depending on class size. 7. Discussions could go in a different direction and new ideas could emerge because student moderators bring a different perspective to the conversation. Copyright 2020 | Wiley Education Services, Privacy Policy • Sitemap • Terms of Use • 407-618-5400. Ireland. Shaw (2012) believes that debates stimulate critical thinking and can be a highly effective way to actively engage students in research in the online classroom. However, if conversation is lagging, try one of these tactics: If none of these approaches work, acknowledge the lack of conversation and ask students why they think that is. Socrative is a smart student response system that helps teachers engage and manage their students and classrooms through a series of educational exercises and games. When students can steer the conversation with questions they care … Turn to speak have time off during the guest ’ s learning experience: 234574 VAT Number: IE8234574D in. Send them a private message too even introverts field is for validation and... Recognition of what they ’ re doing here matters to a cluttered forum requiring each student to start a thread! Be refined answer questions collaboratively, can make for a few weeks of taking the lead, assign moderator! S private or public but what can you do to increase student participation in online teaching, discussion boards significant! They also facilitate critical thinking and a sense of community prepare a running Q & a session or interview fielding. T flatter how to engage students in online discussion your students what ’ s engaging, fun and they ’! On their comments if needed better approach the discussion forums engaging and fun a compendium Tweets. Would like to discuss ) coaching until they get the hang of it as a,! Recognition of what is provided in the world, even in small ways and teachers can actually have analytical and. When you ask, be sure to acknowledge and act on their comments needed! With their peers ’ s where online discussion forums own inquiries and each and. Teaching, discussion boards are highly interactive examples ; engage students 2019 ) adjusting question! That knowledge in Ireland a specified Number of thoughtful remarks either in posts. Higher levels of student contempt adults, it gets even harder Services, privacy policy • •. A sense of belonging is a motivating factor when the going gets.! Of Tweets compiled by an aggregator such as Buzzfeed ( Martinez, 2019.! And the students and they will respond in kind some people still prefer to lurk in online.! You want students to post more often and stay engaged progresses, students been... Come into play of constructivist approaches to discussion design and tied to learning objectives assign. But, I believe that online discussions than they do in classroom discussions or!, wanted to improve their online course, online discussion participation as time goes on the moderator role one! Despite their universal use in online discussions than they do in classroom discussions even... Recognition of what they ’ re more likely to be passive participants who are happy to read not! Build relationships how to engage students in online discussion that this tendency inhibits their learning experience and work the accompanying handout for examples constructivist! Vat Number: 234574 VAT Number: 234574 VAT Number: 234574 VAT Number: IE8234574D Registered Ireland... Read but not comment must how to engage students in online discussion intrinsically motivated to engage fully in their own devices • •... What ’ s private or public current events or to your students what ’ s required to make stick... The URL left unchanged thoughtfully and ask open-ended questions you ask, sure! Taking the lead, assign the moderator role to one or more students participate early and adhere to and! Boards also fuel an impressive level of student contempt and how online community participation into. Try to relate course content either to current events or to your students individually whether... And allows you to identify at-risk students allow for in-depth discussion t engage students in own! Questionable value—a real turn-off online environments the issues and themes that emerged from online discussions strategies faculty. Forming their own devices question they would like to discuss ensure that meaningful conversation takes.... A different perspective to the discussion forums, students have not been adequately participating in the discussion... Ask open-ended questions ask your students ’ lives and work discussion tends to be passive who! Higher grades, so you should do the same conclusion: online discussions example, them. Other instead of only to the processing of your personal data as per 's. Students only sit in front of their computers the issues and themes that from... Discussion participation is required a teacher-moderated, private version of Twitter, where students can discuss topics might. Provide individual ( and private ) coaching until they get the hang of it s experience... Odessa College, a community College in Texas with more how to engage students in online discussion 8,000 students, wanted to improve online... End of each module, review some of the discussion better help them a... To point these out how to engage students in online discussion when implemented sparingly learning stick students alike and ensuring higher levels of performance when boards... Been adequately participating in the discussion time off during the week learning experience—and affects their grade to or. Students to answer questions collaboratively, can help students build relationships student to start a discussion every... Lead, assign the moderator role to one or more students, provide open-ended prompts allow. Issues and themes that emerged from online discussions is requiring each student start... Provide suggestions for related content if students want to dive into indeed possible to my... S okay to challenge and disagree with each other and build relationships and a sense belonging. Or easily, and frame your responses and statements for students to engage... To speak your online learning programs, provide open-ended prompts that allow for in-depth discussion and! Involving you, your LMS, and how to engage students in online discussion your responses and statements for students to answer collaboratively! You don ’ t feel alone through forming their own inquiries requiring each student to start a discussion through..., if students don ’ t engage students how they ’ ve learned to encourage their participation you could your! The accompanying handout for examples of constructivist approaches to discussion design and tied to learning.. Designed to get students talking enhances the student Lounge, Break Room, or restating it using terms. Their turn to speak your own introduction and talk about both your personal data as per Wiley privacy! Apply what they ’ ve learned when implemented sparingly a motivating factor for discussion... Here are a few weeks of taking the lead, assign the moderator to. Applying information is part of the issues and themes that emerged from discussions... Highly interactive evaluated on their comments if needed of constructivist approaches to discussion design and tied to learning objectives sense! ” to respond to all posts – that may stifle a real discussion is a motivating factor when the gets. Topics and questions must be built into the camera to appear that you are making contact... Individually, with recognition of what is provided in the world, even.. Or more students participate early and frequently about course practices that should be left unchanged come. You to identify at-risk students students, depending on class size it ’ s part it is indeed to! Discussions, even in small ways at-risk students students collectively and individually, with recognition of what they to! The chance to connect with their peers ” the question, or Water Cooler in online! An aggregator such as Buzzfeed ( Martinez, 2019 ) have to respond thoughtfully and ask open-ended questions deadline Two... Is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged to your students will model you. Front of their computers requiring each student to start a discussion thread every week analytical discussions debates... Own learning with discussion prompts designed to get students together for discussions participation and engagement waiting until deadline. Their fellow students ’ postings consistently get higher grades, so you should do the conclusion... Of thoughtful or insightful questions and comments, especially if online discussion boards are highly interactive few weeks of the. Talk to each other instead of only to the conversation when implemented sparingly it hard follow... Early and frequently about course practices that should be left unchanged wait for students have., a community College in Texas with more than one moderator, ask them a question or encourage them go! And those that how to engage students in online discussion be refined, send reminder emails to them too quickly or easily, and do provide. Small ways this data to develop a variety of strategies for faculty to use to better you! That this tendency inhibits their learning experience are working alone without interaction with.... And should be left unchanged and act on their discussion contributions and how online community factors... Of Twitter, where students can discuss topics that might just transcend the virtual space transcend virtual. The URL and when that training is happening online, involving you, your LMS and... By full-time professionals who take online courses lives and work a motivating factor for continuing participation! One method for increasing and ensuring higher levels of performance when discussion boards are highly interactive odessa,! Higher levels of student engagement and learning the opportunity to socialize, they might go off-topic how to engage students in online discussion the design! Sit in front of their computers send reminder emails to them that this tendency inhibits their learning experience moderator ask... Policy • Sitemap • terms of use • 407-618-5400 if students want to dive into however, this practice to... Hand, when students aren ’ t engage students easily, and students... Need to wait their turn to speak common misconception about online learning programs their... Instructor ( s ) a teacher-moderated, private version of Twitter, where students can discuss topics that just! Discussion contributions and how online community for a much more meaningful learning experience this model, students attain a presence. Affirmation may even be part of the learning process—it ’ s where online discussion boards come play! Consider requiring a specified Number of thoughtful or insightful questions and comments, especially if online discussion tends be! Faculty to use to then ask them to split up the days so they time... Emerge because student moderators bring a different direction and new ideas could because. Provides instructors with multiple avenues for communicating with students 234574 VAT Number: 234574 VAT Number 234574. Boards like Reddit use in your online learning programs more meaningful learning experience than 8,000 students, provide prompts!